Staying close to a child, and steady in yourself, when you are apart for the holidays
There is a particular stillness to a house on a holiday morning when the children are somewhere else. The table is set for fewer people than it was built for. The kitchen smells the way it always has on Thanksgiving, and the chair where a boy used to sit and steal olives before the blessing stands empty.
A great many parents and grandparents will know that stillness this year, from the last Thursday in November through Hanukkah, Christmas and New Year’s Day. Some share their children under a parenting plan that hands Thanksgiving to one house and Christmas to the other and reverses the order the following year. There are grandparents who hosted the family for thirty years and now wait, often without being told anything, to learn whether there will be a place for them. Hardest of all is the parent or grandparent who has been cut off from a child entirely and cannot say when they will next see that child’s face.
What follows is meant for all of them. It is drawn from what parents and grandparents in these circumstances have found helps, both in keeping a bond alive across the distance and in getting through the day itself.
Before the day arrives
The holidays that go worst are usually the ones nobody talked about ahead of time. If you share a schedule with your child’s other parent, raise the season now, before Thanksgiving week is upon you, and say plainly which days matter most to you. A father who cares deeply about Christmas Eve may find he can give up Christmas afternoon without much grief, and the other household may be relieved to hear it. Arrangements settled in early November tend to hold up far better than ones patched together on the twenty-third of December.
Children need some preparation as well, though it need not be elaborate. Tell them where they will be, when they will see you next, and that you will be all right in the meantime. A child of separated parents often carries a private worry about the parent who will be alone on the holiday, and hearing that you have plans of your own, and that you mean it, takes that worry off small shoulders.
Your own sadness is better shared with the grown-ups in your life. A child can hear that you will miss them without being asked to look after you.
On the day itself
If you are able to call or send a message, give some thought to when. Many parents let the morning belong to the other household and wait until afternoon, when the turkey has been carved or the presents opened and the excitement has settled. A child who is not pulled away from the table can enjoy the day without guilt, and a call at four o’clock tells them just as surely that you were thinking of them.
A short text can do as much good as a long conversation. Something on the order of “Hope you’re having a wonderful day, I love you” asks nothing of a child and leaves them feeling remembered.
Small rituals help too, and they have the advantage of working when no one can get to a phone. A grandmother might tuck a familiar scarf or a photograph into an overnight bag. A father and daughter might agree that whenever either of them hears a particular carol, each will know the other is thinking of them. Some families draw a little heart on the back of a child’s hand before the visit, so that every glance down is a reminder.
A word, too, for the parent who has the children on the holiday. Helping them call their mother or father, or their grandparents, costs you ten minutes of the afternoon, and your children will remember that you did it long after they have forgotten what was under the tree.
A holiday on your own calendar
A holiday was never really a date on the calendar. It is the people gathered and the things they do together year after year, and both of those can be moved. Many families hold their celebration on the first day they are together again and keep every tradition intact, the same dishes and ornaments, the candles lit in their usual order, the same late night. In Britain and Canada, where children often change houses on Boxing Day, many families have quietly made the twenty-sixth a second Christmas of its own.
Children take to this more readily than adults expect. Most eight-year-olds hear the news of two Thanksgivings as a stroke of luck.
The extra days can be put to good use. Some parents lay out a hunt through the house for hidden presents, or have the cookie dough waiting when the children come through the door. Grandparents can do the same, and a second Thanksgiving at Grandma’s on the Saturday after may well become the tradition the grandchildren talk about when they are grown.
When the line has gone quiet
Not every parent or grandparent has the choice of a phone call. Some have been blocked. Some mail cards year after year and never learn whether they arrived. Some hold a court order that promises holiday contact and face a household that will not honor it. For these families the season is not bittersweet but plainly painful, and no one does them any kindness by pretending otherwise.
If this is your situation, keep writing, even when you cannot send what you write. A good many parents and grandparents keep a box of dated cards and letters for the day a child is old enough to ask whether anyone was thinking of them all those years. The answer will be waiting in the box.
Keep a plain record as well, of the calls you placed, the messages you sent, and the visits that were scheduled and did not take place. Keep every exchange calm and courteous, since others may read those messages someday. And do not speak against the other parent where the child can hear, however strong the temptation.
Families in this position should also know that waiting is seldom the answer. When a child who was once close to a parent or grandparent turns away suddenly and completely, often repeating complaints that sound as if they came from someone else, that refusal is not necessarily the child’s own last word. People who work with these families have found that the longer a separation runs, the harder it becomes to mend, and a season spent hoping things will sort themselves out is rarely time on your side.
If holiday contact is written into your parenting plan and is being withheld, do not let the season pass in silence. Talk with a family law attorney promptly about enforcing the order, and look for a counselor trained in Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy who also has experience reuniting children with a parent they have been kept from. Grandparents should know that visitation rights vary considerably from one state to the next, which makes local advice essential.
Looking after yourself in the meantime
A hard day is allowed. Some parents spend part of the morning in tears and then wash their face, put on a coat, and go out. Others decide they will not try to enjoy the holiday at all and will only get through it, which is an honest decision and nothing to be ashamed of.
It does help to have somewhere to be. Spend the day with a brother or sister, an old friend, a houseful of nieces and nephews, or anyone who would be glad of your company. Go to church or synagogue, take yourself to a film and a good dinner, or get out of town for a night. Serving a meal at a shelter or a church supper fills the hours with people who are glad you came.
The quiet hours can also be spent on the child. Wrap the presents for your own celebration, plan the reunion, put up the tree and leave the top branches for them to finish. Then keep your mind where it does the most good, on what is still yours and on the day you will be together again.
Together again
Holidays apart are different, and nothing written here will make them the same as having a child beside you. But a bond tended patiently, with a few small rituals and a steady heart, holds up far better than most people fear. The day will come when you are together again, and the celebration you have been saving will have been worth the wait.
From all of us at the Family Preservation Alliance, our warmest wishes to every parent and grandparent this Thanksgiving and through the holidays, whether your family sits around one table this year or several.
The Family Preservation Alliance works to protect families from systems that disrupt the bonds between parents, grandparents, and children. If you are facing the holidays apart and need support, contact us at family.alliance@aol.com or visit familypreservationalliance.org. Free weekly support meetings for families affected by trauma and estrangement are also offered through TAR Anon® at taranon.org.
This article offers general information and is not legal advice. For questions about a parenting plan or visitation, please consult a family law attorney in your state.